Why Soap and Glory’s Supercat liner doesn’t live up to the hype

Soap and Glory Supercat eyeliner
So this is going to be a little controversial. I have seen this Soap and Glory Supercat eyeliner all over the blogosphere for the last few months, and when I asked for recommendations for a new eyeliner in a bbloggers chat, numerous people recommended it to me. So naturally I assumed this was gong to be the greatest invention since MAC lipsticks and I picked one up to try out.

I tested one out on my hand in store and it seemed pretty good, I liked the felt tip nib and thought that application would be mess free, unlike some of my favourite gel based liners. So into the basket it went! I tried it out for work the very next morning, and as usual I went through the motions of my makeup routine, and after adding a delicate wash of eyeshadow, I reached for Supercat to create my go to flicks.
Soap and Glory Supercat eyeliner
The first eye was ok. It wasn’t as black as I could have hoped for, but it was fairly easy to control the flick which is great for applying make up at the crack of dawn. But when I got to the second flick the colour was almost grey. Not the strong bold black that I wanted. I tried to go over the line a couple of times, and it did go a bit darker but it ended up bodging it slightly and it added an extra 5 minutes onto my routine – which is not great on a work day!

So the next morning I decided I would give it another go, I left the eyeshadow out this time to see if it made a difference. Just like last time, the first eye was ok, but by the second eye the colour was just as rubbish as the morning before. This is really frustrating because I expect eyeliner to be a solid colour and apply consistently. I have to come to the conclusion that the liner just can’t handle being applied on top of makeup, which is a shame as most people to wear a little something something underneath whether it is full on eyemakeup or just a touch of concealer.

Soap and Glory Supercat eyeliner swatch

You can even see in the swatch above, that on bare skin the pigmentation is pretty naff with a fading toward the ends of the lines. For a shade called “carbon black extreme”, this just isn’t very black or extreme. Perhaps I have been spoiled by higher end liner, but for me, this just doesn’t hit the mark and I wont be continuing to use the Supercat eyeliner which is a shame as I had such high expectations for it.

What do you thing of Supercat? What eyeliner do you recommend?